Times Of Swaziland: RATINGS ON INDIVIDUAL PLAYER PERFORMANCE

RATINGS ON INDIVIDUAL PLAYER PERFORMANCE
================================================================================
The Editor on 04/12/2018 00:47:00


Sir,
I have always been intrigued with the player ratings undertaken by your local
sports reporters and a recent player rating, following Mbabane Swallows’
performance in Tanzania has only deepened my curiosity on ratings on individual
player performance.
I’m certainly not a human resources practitioner, neither am I technical on
football issues, however, I am keen to understand on whether your reporters have
what perhaps is a standard player performance index or whether they have a set
of values they look at when a rating on individual performance is undertaken.
It obviously isn’t easy for a person of my caliber to appreciate a situation
when a player is given what probably depicts a horrendous performance, and is
allocated a 2/10 and is further described as ‘not being Swallows material’,
yet in the coach’s assessment he’s good enough to play a full 90 minutes.
Individuals
Perhaps I am missing the boat here; however I think rating individuals in a team
sport surely should be a complex task, primarily because of the team structure.
Players in a soccer team in my opinion have varied roles and each role in my
understanding requires a different set of skills and this probably becomes more
complex if a player plays a variety of positions in a game, e.g.
if the player starts a game as a midfielder and ends up finishing the match as a
defender. Am I missing something in player ratings or maybe your reporters have
a scientific formula or performance index that they use? I’d certainly
appreciate it if they could shed some light on what is obviously a dark room for
me.
Nkosingiphile Jele