LOBAMBA – Eswatini Minister for Justice and Constitutional Affairs, Prince Simelane has said that the courts will determine whether the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) should be merged with the Human Rights and Integrity Commission.
The minister said the matter was currently before the courts following a case where the issue was raised.
He was responding to questions in Parliament yesterday, where Lobamba Lomdzala Member of Parliament (MP) Marwick Khumalo sought clarity on the proposed merger and whether the government’s position was consistent with Section 164 of the Constitution.
The debate arose after Hhukwini MP, Alec Lushaba posed an oral question and on effectiveness of the Human Rights and Integrity Commission, with the minister acknowledging that the absence of enabling legislation had left several of its functions at a standstill.
Prince Simelane explained that the Human Rights Commission was responsible for protecting and promoting the rights of emaSwati, as well as ensuring integrity among people in positions of power in both the public and private sectors.
He said Section 164 of the Constitution empowered the commission to investigate complaints relating to violations of fundamental rights, corruption and abuse of office.
The commission, he added, was also mandated to make findings and work with the Office of the Attorney General and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions.
However, the minister said the commission did not have its own enabling legislation, with its mandate currently provided for under the Constitution.
He said a Bill was before Parliament to give the institution the legal framework required to discharge its responsibilities effectively.
The proposed legislation would also provide for its independence in financial matters and enable it to employ the necessary personnel.
“Nothing bars the commission from publicising its reports. It does that through quarterly reports and also shares with the media,” the minister said, responding to concerns about why the commission was not making its findings public.
MP Marwick Khumalo then raised the question of the proposed merger between the ACC and the Human Rights and Integrity Commission.
He reminded the minister that his predecessor had been working on legislation that would place the ACC under the Human Rights Commission. He wanted to know whether the proposed law would be consistent with the Constitution.
Khumalo also questioned whether the Human Rights and Integrity Commission was adequately remunerated compared to other government commissions.
He further referred to the position reportedly taken by the late Chief Justice Bheki Maphalala, who had indicated that the ACC should be merged with the Human Rights Commission because its existing institutional arrangement was ineffective.
The MP questioned whether failure to implement the proposed merger, which he believed was required by the Constitution, had contributed to the accumulation of corruption cases.
Hhukwini MP Alec Lushaba also questioned whether the absence of enabling legislation was the reason the commission was not operating effectively.
In response, Prince Simelane agreed that the legislation was critical to the commission’s operations.
“Hhukwini MP is right. Indeed, the law is the one that is critical. Without it, a lot is not happening right, a lot is at a standstill. The MP is actually answering himself,” he said.
However, when Khumalo pressed him on the merger, the minister said the government had received a legal opinion advising that the ACC should remain a standalone institution.
Khumalo interjected, insisting that the minister was referring to an opinion while he was asking about a constitutional provision.
“The prince is speaking of opinion, I am talking of a constitutional provision. He is not telling us if we must set aside the Constitution, he is just telling us his opinion. Does he mean that we must set aside the Constitution?” Khumalo asked.
In response, Prince Simelane said the matter was now before the courts, which would determine whether the two institutions should be merged.
“In soccer we had this tendency of kicking the next player ‘ku-jutha’. I prefer to do just that when it comes to this issue. That issue is currently in court to determine whether the two should merge or not,” he said.