Home News Local trucks must come first in next Railways tender – PAC
News

Local trucks must come first in next Railways tender – PAC

Share
Public Accounts Committee members and Members of Parliament Nomkhosi Masuku and Tsembeni Magongo following the proceedings of the sitting.
Share

LOBAMBA – Members of Parliament (MPs) have called on Eswatini Railways (ESR) to ensure that local trucking companies are given priority in the next coal haulage tender.

The MPs argued that the previous arrangement with South African logistics giant, Grindrod, left many emaSwati counting heavy losses.

The issue dominated proceedings when ESR appeared before the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) for the second time yesterday to respond to findings contained in Auditor General (AG) Timothy Matsebula’s Compliance Audit Report for the financial year ended March 31, 2024.

Besides concerns over procurement irregularities relating to the leasing of locomotives from Grindrod Logistics Africa, the PAC members used the opportunity to demand safeguards that would prevent local truck owners from being sidelined in future commercial agreements.

According to the AG, ESR failed to follow the prescribed procurement procedures when leasing four GL28SCC-DC diesel-electric locomotives, serial numbers GMU 1202, GMU 118, GMU 115 and GMU 110, from Grindrod Logistics Africa.

Matsebula said it was unclear which procurement method had been used when engaging the company, contrary to Section 42(1) of the Procurement Act, 2011, which requires procuring entities to use approved procurement methods for all acquisitions.

He said the procurement process did not demonstrate economy, transparency, fairness or competitiveness, raising concerns that value for money may not have been achieved.

Responding to the findings, Acting ESR Chief Executive Officer Sandile Dlamini conceded that the AG’s observations were correct, explaining that the decision was made after Grindrod sought to move its coal stockpile to Mozambique as quickly as possible.

He said the customer became concerned that coal was accumulating at the stockpile, while international prices were declining, prompting the company to bring in its own locomotives to accelerate transportation.

“In hindsight, we should have stopped the exercise until all legal procurement requirements had been complied with. The locomotives were transporting Grindrod’s coal to Mozambique using our drivers,” Dlamini told the committee.

He revealed that the controversial locomotive lease agreement has since been terminated and ESR was currently winding up the remaining contractual obligations.

According to Dlamini, two of the locomotives were involved in an accident and were repaired by the customer. He said discussions were continuing over insurance payments and outstanding amounts owed to ESR, adding that while Grindrod had begun removing spare parts used on the locomotives, the locomotives themselves remained on ESR premises.

He further disclosed that following the AG’s intervention, ESR had advertised a fresh tender for leasing locomotives.

The procurement process had progressed to the adjudication stage and awaited the intention-to-award phase. While the procurement issue was under scrutiny, MPs shifted focus to the devastating impact the collapse of the coal transportation project had on local truck owners.

Nhlambeni MP Manzi Zwane questioned whether any feasibility study had been conducted before the project commenced, saying many emaSwati had invested heavily in trucks and equipment after being encouraged by the anticipated coal haulage business.

He noted that numerous truck owners were now losing their vehicles to banks after the business failed to generate the expected returns and sought clarity on whether proper contractual arrangements had been in place from the outset.

Dvokodvweni MP, Sicelo Shabalala, said many emaSwati had been impoverished by the manner in which the project unfolded. He observed that while local transport operators had initially benefitted from transporting coal, the situation changed when Grindrod introduced its own fleet of trucks, leaving local contractors without work despite having borrowed substantial amounts to purchase trucks and machinery.

*Full article available on Pressreader*  

Eswatini Railways acting Chief Executive Officer Sandile Dlamini and Legal Dennis Ntshangase responding to queries raised during the PAC sitting.
Eswatini Railways acting Chief Executive Officer Sandile Dlamini and Legal Dennis Ntshangase responding to queries raised during the PAC sitting.

Share

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don't Miss

MPs push for E1 500 elderly grant

MBABANE- Members of Parliament have renewed calls for an increase in the elderly grant, with some questioning progress in formulating regulations to guide...

Farmers urged to sell livestock as over 50 cattle die

NHLANGANO - Farmers in the Shiselweni Region have been urged to sell their livestock as over 50 cattle have died due to the ...

President hosts Team Eswatini to dinner in Dakar

DAKAR – Team Eswatini athletes received words of encouragement from the country's Olympic leadership during a special dinner hosted by the EOCGA President ...

Court dismisses ESRIC senior compliance officer’s disciplinary challenge

MBABANE – The Industrial Court has dismissed an application by an Eswatini Royal Insurance Corporation senior compliance officer, who wanted the court to...

Another cup final for MaMkhize’s Eswatini team

(At Somhlolo National Stadium) Highlanders AM.....(0)0 Ubombo Sugar........(0)0  Highlanders won 5-3 on penalties) MBABANE - Mbabane Highlanders AM reached the PLE Charity Cup...

Related Articles

23 issues await Acting CJ Mumcy

BY KWANELE DLAMINI AND MBONGISENI NDZIMANDZE MBABANE – Acting Chief Justice (CJ)...

New bus fares to take effect next week

MANZINI – Commuters will start paying higher bus fares next week after...

Inner council fined 86 cattle over land

MBABANE – The Eluhlendlweni Inner Council has been fined 86 cattle for...

Stop chiefs from issuing umphakatsi stamps –MPs

LOBAMBA-Some Members of Parliament (MPs) have demanded that chiefs be stripped off...